Dividend Danger Zone: Are bond proxies yielding 5 per cent plus a buy or value trap?

Bond proxy stocks, those that on the surface offer a safe and predicable income, have thrived under the decade-long loose monetary policy environment. But with expectations of an interest rate rise being pencilled in for August, some investors have moved to cash in their chips. 

Our dividend danger zone screen, which uses a range of filters to pick potential yield traps, casts doubt over three stocks in the utilities sector, which tends to be viewed by investors as classic bond proxy territory. Water company share prices in particular have come under pressure of late, with some investors fretting that they may be nationalised if Jeremy Corbyn becomes prime minister.  

Water businesses Pennon and United Utilities are both offering dividend yields above 5 per cent, as is power company National Grid, but all have seen their earnings downgraded by analysts. Moreover, the three businesses’ dividend cover scores are far away from being deemed comfortable. 

Stock in focus 

In the case of United Utilities, which has seen its share price fall by 26 per cent over the past year, a 5.3 per cent dividend yield looks attractive on paper, because its balance sheet contains cheap debt that has been financed for 30 or more years. According to Simon McGarry of Canaccord Genuity Wealth Management, this ‘should boost returns on equities for many years.’ 

But he adds that the next regulatory period will be tougher for water companies; in addition he points out that ‘without achieving cost savings and efficiencies from its operations, United Utilities will have a hard time earning more than its cost of capital.’ 

Last month industry regulator Ofwat told water companies to put the customer before shareholders’ interests. Rachel Fletcher, Ofwat's chief executive, said: ‘We are making moves on three fronts to get a better outcome for customers.

‘First, any company with high levels of debt which boosts their returns will be expected to share gains with customers. Second, companies need to ensure dividend policies are transparent and make sure they’ve met their obligations to customers before making dividend payments. And third, we want to see that water company executives are rewarded for delivering for customers, not just shareholders.’ 

Other concerns 

Our dividend danger zone screen started six months ago and the same names keep on cropping up as potential value traps. 

Card Factory, which boasts the highest forecast dividend yield (7.5 per cent) out of the nine shares in the dividend danger zone screen, has retained its place on the list each month since December. In January the company suffered its second profit warning in four months.  

Imperial Brands has featured on the list since January, a surprising entrant given that the firm has grown its dividend for the past 15 years. In addition, its management team remains committed to growing the dividend by 10 per cent per year.  

Essentra, which manufactures plastic products, has appeared previously, as has Manx Telecom, which in late 2017 lost roughly a fifth of its post-pay revenues. 

The two new entrants this month are Vodafone and U and I Group, a property developer. 

The mechanics behind the screen 

We apply the following filters: a market cap of over £200 million, a dividend yield of 4 per cent (higher than the FTSE 100 average) and a dividend cover score of below 1.4 times. Two other filters were also applied: the first filtered out companies that appear in a financially sound position to pay off their debts, while the second excluded firms with positive earnings per share momentum for the next three months.

-10 high yielding shares in the FTSE 100: how safe are their dividends? 

Keep up to date with all the latest financial news and investment tips by signing up to our newsletter. Email subscribers will also receive a free print copy of Money Observer magazine.

Subscribe to Money Observer Magazine

Be the first to receive expert investment news and analysis of shares, funds, regions and strategies we expect to deliver top returns, plus free access to the digital issues on your desktop or via the Money Observer App.

Subscribe now

Add new comment