There's no doubting that Persimmon (PSN) has traded well in recent months, buoyed in particular by the government's Help to Buy scheme for first-time buyers. But does this really justify the 63 per cent surge in its share price in the past year and the doubling in the price since the Brexit vote?
Some analysts clearly think the market has got too excited on the housebuilding sector, especially given expectations that chancellor Philip Hammond will try to woo the young vote with initiatives to speed them onto the property ladder.
In particular, there's been talk about radical reform of planning rules when Hammond stands up to deliver his Budget later this month.
Persimmon said today that achieving detailed planning consent was as challenging as ever and that it was time for more effective processes to allow the industry to increase the number of active outlets and overall output.
But how far Hammond will go to help the industry is open to doubt. Barclays analysts issued a note last week in which they downgraded housebuilders because they believed expectations may have run ahead of themselves.
They said: 'We are not signalling that we believe housebuilding fundamentals have deteriorated. Or that we expect the greater likelihood of rate rises to upset the apple cart.
'However, very strong share price performance leaves little scope for disappointment and we believe expectations of further government measures could be overblown.'
The broker downgraded Persimmon and Berkeley (BKG) to underweight and Redrow (RDW), Bellway (BWY) and Taylor Wimpey (TW.) to equalweight.
In this context, it's hardly surprising that Persimmon shares were punished today after what appeared to be a steady if unspectacular trading update. Shares were 107p lower at 2,767p, a drop of nearly 4 per cent.
The group reported about £909 million of forward sales reserved beyond 2017, an increase of 10 per cent on the same point last year. Pricing remains firm across its regional markets.
Liberum analyst Charlie Campbell said the information not included in the update from Persimmon was more significant. He said: 'By omitting the usual metric of private sales per site per week and replacing it with a comment that total sales per site per week were flat suggests that private sales per site per week are likely to be slightly slower than last year.'
Persimmon also declined to give margin guidance in the statement, suggesting to Liberum's Campbell that margins in H2 will be consistent with H1.
Persimmon’s trading update sent other UK-listed housebuilders into the red yesterday (8 November). It was a similar story this morning as at 9.30am Persimmon had slipped 2.7 per cent, while Barratt Developments (-2.5 per cent) and Taylor Wimpey (-2.3 per cent) had also posted declines in early trading.
Keep up to date with all the latest personal finance news and investment tips by signing up to our newsletter. Email subscribers will also receive a free print copy of Money Observer magazine.
This article was originally published on our sister website Interactive Investor.
Subscribe to Money Observer Magazine
Be the first to receive expert investment news and analysis of shares, funds, regions and strategies we expect to deliver top returns, plus free access to the digital issues on your desktop or via the Money Observer App.Subscribe now