Buy, Hold, Sell: FP CRUX European Special Situations

The aim of FP CRUX European Special Situations is to ‘buy global businesses listed in Europe’, James Milne, co-fund manager says. Milne has run the fund alongside Richard Pease since its inception in 2009. The fund now holds around £1.9 billion and over the past five years has returned 122 per cent.

The managers focus on European companies – which account for 93 per cent of its assets – that have ‘resilient earnings’. The companies they invest in, Milne says, are those which they believe will be able to withstand downturns. The managers like companies that dominate niche markets. They also place a ‘heavy focus on good management’, and are suspicious of shares on too high multiples and those with large amounts of debt.

Buy: Huhtamaki (HEL: HUH1V)

Huhtamaki produces food and drink packaging. Based and listed in Finland, one of its leading products is disposable paper cups for coffee. Within this market, Milne says, it has a ‘very secure global oligopoly. There are not many large peers in its sector that can make so many types of coffee cup.’

Investment in the company, says Milnes, gives useful exposure to the growth of high-street coffee businesses and enables ‘piggy-backing off Costa Coffee’. In the US also, there is a shift from plastic coffee cups to paper cups, giving Huhtamaki some attractive growth opportunities. The company also has growth potential from its other speciality: flexible packaging. Such packaging is popular for sale in many emerging markets, particularly India.

The firm’s expansion in the US market has come with growing pains and associated costs. At the same time, changes to India’s VAT system have resulted in a drop-off of growth in sales there. But these are both temporary blips, Milne believes, making the company a solid buy right now.

Bought: Small purchase in November 2016 at €35. Substantial purchase in August 2017 at €33.

Hold: Burckhardt Compression Holding AG (SWX: BCHN)

Milne points to Burckhardt Compression as a share which, although it is not in the FP CRUX European Special Situations portfolio, would be an obvious choice to retain if investors already owned it.

Based in Switzerland, the company produces reciprocating compressors that use liquid natural gas (LNG) and they have a variety of industrial uses. Like Huhktamki, he says, it is ‘also quite a solid oligopoly, but making compressors, which gives it a large after-market’. The margins on its products are quite high and the return on capital ‘way above 30 or 40 per cent’. As an added bonus, the company has very rarely had any debt.

-Our top 10 fund tips from 2017

So why not buy? The market for LNG powered ships is very cyclical, and the LNG-powered shipbuilding industry is prone to over-investment. Right now, ‘no one wants to buy any such ships’. Milne sums up Burkhardt thus: ‘Solid company, cyclical downturn for that industry.’ ‘If you own this,’ he says, ‘sit on it and wait for the cycle to turn.’

Sell: Assa Abloy AB (STO: ASSA-B)

Milne held the Swedish lock making company Assa Abloy for three years. When he purchased it, it was a business on the up. A few years before, the company had appointed a new chief executive who kick-started a large acquisition strategy. The company began to buy up small, often family-owned locksmiths. At the same time, the locksmith industry was particularly attractive to Milne because it has a lot of pricing power: everyone needs to maintain or replace their locks.

So why sell? First, notes Milne, it looked as though the chief executive might leave the company (which he subsequently did after Milne sold out). He played a dominant role in the company’s management, and Milne was concerned about what might happen after he left. Secondly, the price/earnings ratio had reached a multiple of 22 – too high, in Milne’s view.

Finally, Milne felt that while initially successful, the acquisition strategy of Assa Abloy was starting to see diminishing returns. As it grew bigger, each new acquisition made less of an impact on the company. To continue growing at a similar rate, larger acquisitions would have to be found, adding a new layer of risk.

Bought: November 2013 at €317 (note: there was a 1 for 3 share split on 2 June 2015, therefore price would become €105). Sold: November 2016 at €164. 

Keep up to date with all the latest financial news and investment tips by signing up to our newsletter. Email subscribers will also receive a free print copy of Money Observer magazine.  

Subscribe to Money Observer Magazine

Be the first to receive expert investment news and analysis of shares, funds, regions and strategies we expect to deliver top returns, plus free access to the digital issues on your desktop or via the Money Observer App.

Subscribe now

Add new comment