How Money Observer’s 2018 fund awards are won

July 13, 2018

Contenders

Funds, including off­shore-domiciled funds, must be members of an Investment Association (IA) sector and offer a ster­ling or hedged to sterling share class. All charity, exempt, institutional and private funds are excluded, as are all passive index-tracking funds.

Each fund must have at least £15 million of assets under management (AUM) as at 31 March 2018 and have at least a three-year qualifying history (no breaks in its history due to any material change in fund structure, objectives or gov­ernance). Contenders for best smaller fund awards are those with AUM of £15 million to £150 million. Contenders for best larger fund awards are those with AUM of £150 million-plus.

Awards are assessed within specified IA sectors, except for UK growth, UK equity income and prop­erty categories, which are assessed by referencing Morningstar sectors.

For these awards we assess the most relevant private investor share class to measure performance. This is the Investment Association’s primary share class: the highest-charging unbundled share class freely available in the retail market.

Quantitative methodology

Data for the awards was provided by Morningstar. Charts (except for property categories) came from FE Analytics.

The filtering process

The funds are ranked from best to worst across two main measures.

First, an overall average is calculated by weighting the first and oldest discrete year with 20 per cent (to 31 March 2016), second dis­crete year with 30 per cent (to 31 March 2017), third most recent discrete year with 40 per cent (to 31 March 2018) and the three-year total return with 10 per cent.

Second, risk-adjusted returns are analysed over three years to 31 March 2018, as defined by the Sharpe ratio. This measure calculates the level of a fund’s return over and above the return of a notional risk-free invest­ment (in this case the ICE GBP Libor 1 Month index). The difference in returns is then divided by the fund’s standard deviation – its vol­atility, or risk measurement.

Contenders are then fil­tered to include only those funds which maintained themselves in one of the top three quartiles in their sector for each of the last three years across the fol­lowing measures:

- three discrete annual periods of one-year risk-adjusted returns, as per Sharpe ratio;

- three discrete annual periods of relative perfor­mance versus the fund’s IA sector.

This filters out weak per­formance, either in terms of weak risk-adjusted returns or weak returns relative to the fund’s sector.

‘Socially conscious’ fund awards

Morningstar defines a socially conscious fund thus: funds that make investments based on such issues as environmental responsibility, human rights, or religious views. A socially conscious fund may take a proactive stance by selectively investing in, for example, environmen­tally friendly companies, or firms with good employee relations. This group also includes funds that avoid investing in companies involved in promoting alco­hol, tobacco, or gambling, or in the defence industry.

Using the same filtering process as above, contend­ers are derived from the fol­lowing IA sectors: equity – any equity-oriented sector; mixed asset – the three mixed investment sectors and flexible investment; bond – UK corporate and UK strategic bond sectors.

Qualitative aspects

• Fund manager’s ten­ure. We favour those with a history of at least three years managing the fund.

• Access to the fund by a wide spectrum of retail investors, thus excluding ‘soft-closed’ funds which could levy an initial fee.

• The fund’s strategy broadly tallies with retail investors’ expectations for the award category.

• Where a fund’s three-year performance (after satisfying the filtering requirements) is signifi­cantly superior to another fund with a better three-year Sharpe ratio, Money Observer may favour the higher-performing fund if its Sharpe ratio is not signifi­cantly lower.

Subscribe to Money Observer Magazine

Be the first to receive expert investment news and analysis of shares, funds, regions and strategies we expect to deliver top returns, plus free access to the digital issues on your desktop or via the Money Observer App.

Subscribe now

Add new comment