Dividend danger zone: are these high yields too good to be true?

In the ‘lower for longer’ interest rate environment, the hunt for income has been one of the dominant themes of the investment landscape since the financial crisis. 

As we approach the start of 2018, with interest rates remaining stubbornly low at 0.5 per cent, reliable income-paying stocks such as the ‘dividend kings’ that have grown payouts for 15 years or more will remain in high demand.  

But, at this stage in the economic cycle, investors face a predicament: it is becoming harder to source income at a sensible price, evidenced by the fact that companies that were perceived as a safe bet on the income front have been bought en masse and as a consequence are now offering low yields as the price has risen. 

For those investors who want to find market-beating yields of 4 per cent plus, certain compromises need to be made, namely a willingness to accept the greater levels of risk involved. Various cyclical business, miners and banks for example, are offering yields of more than 4 per cent, but their ability to keep writing dividend cheques is somewhat reliant on the overall health of the economy remaining robust.

Here, as a part of a new occasional series, Money Observer has teamed up with wealth manager Canaccord to highlight dividend shares that may struggle to deliver on the dividend front. 

We asked Simon McGarry, a senior equity analyst at Canaccord Genuity Wealth Management, to create the dividend danger zone share screen. McGarry filtered through the 700-odd names in the FTSE All Share index and added the following filters: a market cap of over £200 million, a dividend yield of 4 per cent (higher than the FTSE 100 average) and a dividend cover score of below 1.4 times. Two other filters were also applied: the first filtered out companies that appear in a financially sound position to pay off their debts, while the second excluded firms where earnings have been upgraded by analysts. 

After factoring in all of the above, just six shares remained, highlighted in the table below. However, McGarry points out that none of these shares should be viewed as ‘sell’ recommendations. On the contrary, some of the shares that are potentially in dividend danger may actually pique the interest of contrarian investors. 

‘There are lots of different ways private investors can assess whether a dividend looks vulnerable; the screen I have put together highlights on certain metrics those that are in the danger zone on the basis of certain metrics,’ he says.


Forecast dividend yield (%)

Dividend cover score (times)







Card Factory













Source: Canaccord Genuity Wealth Management. Date: 4 December 2017 

Stock in focus: Inmarsat 

Each month in Money Observer magazine we will look more closely at an individual stock that features in the dividend danger zone. This month we have chosen Inmarsat, a satellite communications business.  

It has been a couple of months to forget for Inmarsat after the firm’s shares fell heavily into the red in November, dipping to a five-year low after the firm lowered its profit guidance for the year.  On a one-year view the share price is down 38 per cent, and as a result its forecast dividend yield has risen, currently offering a 8.4 per cent. 

According to McGarry, Inmarsat is not a dividend darling that is loved by income investors; instead the high yield it is offering today is a function of its heavy share price fall in 2017. He fears there are question marks over the firm’s ability to service the dividend for various reasons, but points out first that there are concerns around its pricing power and sustainability of margins across various divisions, but most notably maritime (which accounts for 50 per cent of its revenues). 

He adds: ‘Capex is likely to stay high and reduce Inmarsat’s ability to pay a dividend. In addition, net debt/EBITDA for 2017 is expected to be a 10-year high. The dividend won’t be covered by earnings in 2017 and 2018. Moreover, a yield of 8 per cent plus seems to suggest the dividend is unsustainable.

Keep up to date with all the latest financial news and investment tips by signing up to our newsletter. Email subscribers will also receive a free print copy of Money Observer magazine. 

Subscribe to Money Observer Magazine

Be the first to receive expert investment news and analysis of shares, funds, regions and strategies we expect to deliver top returns, plus free access to the digital issues on your desktop or via the Money Observer App.

Subscribe now

Add new comment